Skip to content

Harden Locals Oppose Rate Rises

A debate has been sparked in the local community after a June 23 Councillor Column, which saw comments around a previously proposed rate rise before the author of the column was in office.
A vast majority of locals have expressed outrage over this, with Harden locals specifically taking aim at the Council.

The column stated “Much has been made, and rightly so, of the structural deficit in the Hilltops Council budget. This is not a problem that started in 2026, and unless we change some of the fundamentals of how we operate, it’s unlikely to change going forward.”

“There have been proposals that, in order to fix our deficit, we should think of the Council more like a business. We need to operate more as a for-profit enterprise. While, of course, it is sensible for us to be in the black, this, I think, misunderstands the role and purpose of Local Government. Government is not a business. Businesses deliver profits, maximise value for owners and shareholders, and need to have profitable services. This is simply not the case for governments.

How much money does Hilltops make from our road network? Do the park reserves run a profit? What is the point of libraries from a money-making perspective?

“All of these things are public services. Things the government provides to the community for their intrinsic value alone, not merely for the money the government could be making off them. Every dollar spent in libraries, for example, delivers community value over four times that in return. They provide places for people to go and socialise, learning resources, an avenue for reading and education, a place for young people, and a home for community classes. They exist outside a simple profit-and-loss framework.

“We shouldn’t take at face value those who claim cutting Council services and facilities is both an easy and preferred path to financial savings. Because Council is not a business, but also because those services and facilities deliver value well beyond the financial.

“That does not mean that we shouldn’t be financially sustainable. Of course, we need to be; to continue to provide the community with the services and value you all want. But cutting, cutting, and cutting leads us down an inevitable and difficult-to-recover-from path of austerity.

“No one wants to be the one to float the idea of raising rates. Especially in the current cost-of-living environment. But costs for Councils are going up just as much as they are for everyone else. And if we’re truly serious about providing the best we can to the community with roads, parks, pools, and libraries, then we need to get serious about the idea of raising revenue.

“Simply slashing spending won’t cut it. The 2023 SRV proposal was not popular in the community or with some on Council, but had that proposal succeeded, much of the discussion now about our financial position simply would not exist.

“The previous Council deferred the decision to raise rates in 2023 to fully get a picture of our financial situation. Fair enough. But if we go into 2026/27 with a view that the only way forward from here is continued cuts and austerity, there won’t be much of a Council left worth having.”

Immediately, the column faced pushback from the community, who feel they already pay their fair share, especially when facing economic issues at home already as is.

One commenter said, “I can see an SRV coming, I am sure ratepayers already struggling with cost of living pressures are going to be ecstatic. Increasing rates also negatively affect businesses; less disposable money = business downturns.”

A commenter replied to that with a rough calculation, “For a pensioner, the rates are already possibly at about 10% of their pension. If the 2023 SRV had gone through, it would be more than 20% for no tangible change in services. For someone who can’t find work and is on Jobseeker, that could rise from 15% to 30% of their income. I think Hilltops Council should do a thorough assessment of the potential impact of any rate increases on the region before they even consider it.”

The transition to “smart” water meters has become a topic of discussion as many wonder about the overall price of this transition and why it is necessary. The smart water meter rollout is set to continue throughout the coming months.

Whether you are for or against an SRV, now is the time to voice your opinion.

Jack Murray

The South West Slopes Times covers an area approximately the size of Fiji in country NSW. We look after a population of more than 50,000 people with our staff servicing 7 major towns and dozens of villages with our story telling footprint.

We offer weekly print editions at $3 a copy and we also offer digital subscriptions across 3 months $30, 6 months $60 and 12 months $120.

We are one of the last truly local independent family run newspaper businesses in the state.

Contact us today to find out how we can promote your business or organisation across our huge network by emailing ads@thetimes.net.au or by calling 0413 763 216.

If you have a news tip, lead or scoop for us please make contact as we love celebrating our communities. You can contribute articles via our South West Slopes Times website. 

Share this:

Contribute your story

We are always looking for new stories to share with our readers. If you have a story you would like to share, click the 'Contribute' button.