The wind, a ghost of the late afternoon, swept across Mick Sherd Oval, carrying the roar of the crowd and the smell of freshly cut grass. It was a day for legends to be made, for a season’s worth of grit and glory to culminate in one final, brutal contest. This was the George Tooke Shield Grand Final, and at the heart of the storm stood two teams: the Bungendore Tigers and the Harden Hawks.
The Tigers, a team accustomed to victory, had spent the last four years at the pinnacle of the competition. They were a well-oiled machine, their movements precise and their strategy meticulously rehearsed. Their month of rest, a luxury afforded to them by their top-of-the-table finish, meant they were physically fresh and mentally sharp. They played with the quiet confidence of a team that knew its worth, their jerseys a blur of gold and black against the green of the field.
The Hawks, on the other hand, had taken the long road. They had fought their way through the finals, their journey a testament to a new found defensive tenacity. For years, they had been a good attacking side, but this season, something had clicked. They had become a defensive powerhouse, their line a fortress, and it was this unyielding spirit that had carried them all the way to Bungendore. They were tired, yes, but they were also battle-hardened, their bodies and minds accustomed to the pain and pressure of high-stakes football.
The opening minutes of the match were a symphony of colliding bodies and crunching tackles. The Hawks’ forward pack, a group of dedicated work-horses, held their own against the formidable Tigers. They were the underdogs, but they refused to be intimidated, matching the Tigers’ physicality blow for blow in the middle of the field. It was a war of attrition, a relentless test of will and stamina.
The scoreboard reflected the brutal parity of the contest. First, it was Harden who struck, with Tom McIllhatton crossing the line, his try a statement of intent. The conversion was good, and the small pocket of Harden fans erupted. But the Tigers, unfazed, answered almost immediately. Michael Gordon found a gap in the Hawks’ line, and the ever-reliable Zach Smith slotted the conversion with ease.
The game continued in this breathtaking back-and-forth. The Hawks’ coach, watching from the sideline, saw a contest of pure, raw energy. “I thought we dominated and held our own physically in the middle, which hasn’t always been the case against Bungendore,” he would later say. They were forcing the Tigers to expend energy, to work for every inch. Opportunities were created, but the scramble defence from both sides was nothing short of heroic.
The crowd gasped as a high kick sailed through the air. A moment of chaos, a flash of movement, and suddenly, the ball was in the hands of Harry Buckley for the Tigers. He trapped the kick and was gone, scoring from an opportunistic play. The conversion was good, and Bungendore pulled ahead. But the Hawks refused to break. They returned the favour with their own bit of brilliance, a clever kick and regather that ended with Jack Nicolls touching down. McIllhatton converted, and the score was locked at 10-10 as the siren sounded for halftime.
The second half began with the same fierce intensity. Both teams pushed, searching for a crack, a moment of weakness. The Hawks’ coach watched with pride as his team, the players he had nurtured and moulded for years, executed their game plan with precision and heart. He saw the fire in the eyes of his middles—Luke Brown, Corey Lucas, and Steve Anderson—who were putting in a monumental effort, refusing to yield an inch.
And then, Jack Nicolls came alive. Already a standout, he elevated his game to another level in the second half. He was everywhere, a blur of motion and power. He was rewarded for his tireless effort with a second try, a moment that sent a shockwave of hope through the Harden faithful. McIllhatton’s conversion was good, and with a comfortable lead and the clock winding down, it felt like victory was within their grasp.
But this was Bungendore, a team that knew how to win, a team that kept it simple and repeated their well-drilled actions until their opponents buckled. They pushed hard in the final minutes, and with four minutes left on the clock, a moment of controversy unfolded. A penalty was awarded to the Tigers right in front of the posts.
The Hawks were in possession, moving the ball forward, when a marker was deemed to have run into one of their players in the play-the-ball. The Hawks’ coach, watching from the sideline, felt his heart sink. It was a tough call, a bitter pill to swallow. He could hear the grumbles from the Harden fans, the shouts of protest, but he knew the truth of it.
“Harden fans are just going to be super critical and we’re going to be salty about it,” he would say later, “and Bungendore fans are going to say that’s footy, and you know what, it is footy, that’s the way it is.”
Zach Smith stepped up, his expression a mask of calm focus. The kick was a formality for a player of his calibre. The ball sailed through the uprights, and the scoreboard changed to 18-16. With the little time remaining, the Hawks threw everything they had at the Tigers, but it was not enough. The final whistle blew, and the Tigers celebrated a hard-won victory. The loss was a painful one. It was a moment that would be replayed in their minds, a what-if that would linger. The coach knew his players would be hurting.
“It’s a hard one to cop, losing a grand final on a penalty like that,” he admitted. He knew some fans would point to other moments, to goals they felt were wrongly called, but he also knew that these were just the realities of the game. “You’ve just got to suck it up, that’s it,” he said.
Despite the bitterness of defeat, the coach was immensely proud. He had seen his team grow, a group of individuals who had learned to play as one. He praised the individual efforts, highlighting Jack Nicolls as the standout player of the day, a performance so good that he earned the players’ player award. He had no bad performers, he said. Everyone, from the middles to the guys on the bench, had given it their all.
Looking to the future, the coach acknowledged the challenges ahead. For a small club like Harden, in a small town, every year was a battle. They needed to find ways to connect their juniors with their seniors, to attract players, and to find volunteers to keep the club running. It was a constant struggle, a test of resilience and persistence. But he was confident in the foundation they had built.
The players, a group that had been with him for years, were no longer at the start. They understood the structures, the language of the game. He simply had to bring the new faces up to speed.
“We’re confident in what we are doing there now at the Hawks as a playing group,” he said. The challenge for him, as a coach, was to keep it fresh, to keep it interesting.
The Bungendore Tigers were a great team, well-drilled, well-organised, and full of big, strong guys. They had earned their victory. The Hawks had given a meritorious performance, but ultimately, it was a loss.
As the sun began to set on Mick Sherd Oval, casting long shadows across the field, the coach knew that they would be back. They would lick their wounds, learn from their mistakes, and continue to build something special in Harden. The dream of a championship would have to wait, but the spirit of the Hawks was unbroken.
– Tully Potts
The South West Slopes Times covers an area approximately the size of Fiji in country NSW. We look after a population of more than 50,000 people with our staff servicing 7 major towns and dozens of villages with our story telling footprint.
We offer weekly print editions at $3 a copy and we also offer digital subscriptions across 3 months $30, 6 months $60 and 12 months $120.
We are one of the last truly local independent family run newspaper businesses in the state.
Contact us today to find out how we can promote your business or organisation across our huge network by emailing ads@thetimes.net.au or by calling 0413 763 216.
If you have a news tip, lead or scoop for us please make contact as we love celebrating our communities. You can contribute articles via our South West Slopes Times website.